So far, I have explained some of the key characteristics of marketplace network effects. This includes the impact of fragmentation, geographic range, supply differentiation, SaaS integration and engagement. But none of this is remotely useful unless startups can actually get transactions flowing on their marketplace. In order to bootstrap these interactions, marketplaces need to hit a critical mass of demand and supply. In other words, they need to have “liquidity”.
Showing posts with label Airbnb. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Airbnb. Show all posts
1 Jun 2020
4 May 2020
Why Marketplaces Fail: The Role of Engagement
Posted by
Sameer Singh
|
4 May 2020 -- 09:31
|
So far, I have discussed a handful of characteristics that create structural advantages or risks for marketplaces. This includes the geographic range of network effects, supply differentiation, SaaS integration and market fragmentation. Fragmentation is most useful as a first level filter to assess the viability of any marketplace, while the rest are second and third-level screening frameworks to evaluate defensibility and scalability. Another factor that influences the potential of marketplaces is the nature of engagement, i.e. the size and frequency of transactions. While this is less influential than other structural characteristics, it can become a major risk factor for some types of marketplaces.
24 Feb 2020
Defensibility x Scalability = The Marketplace Matrix
Posted by
Sameer Singh
|
24 Feb 2020 -- 09:29
|
In the first part of our marketplace thesis, I explained how we think about the geographic scalability of marketplaces, i.e. we prefer marketplaces where a given unit of supply is accessible to customers across borders as opposed to those where it is restricted to a small local area. We saw that marketplaces with cross-border network effects (e.g. Airbnb), created a lot more value for investors than those with hyperlocal network effects (e.g. Uber). In sports terminology, this is a view of the “offensive” side of the game. But we also need to study the “defensive” side to gauge how well marketplaces can defend themselves from competition and copycats at scale.









